A Tale of Light and Shadow
Fantasy Book Review
I first read Jacob Gowans with his Psion series and absolutely loved it. The first book of the Light and Shadow series really struggled to hold my attention. I normally crank through these type of books but this one took me over a week because I just kept finding better things to do than read something that is only slightly entertaining. Don’t misunderstand, reading the book is not like going to the dentist, more like going to a family wedding. There is some fun to be had, maybe Aunt Maureen starts to grind on one of the groomsmen who is half her age, but at the end of the day, the weekend could have been much better spent.
The story is not bad, a young carpenter by the name of Henry falls hard for a down on his luck nobleman’s daughter named Isabelle. It turns out that the nobleman is a world class prick who puts his daughter in a situation that requires some serious rescuing. Our carpenter enlists some friends and through a barely believable scheme he does that rescuing in epic fashion.
The rest of the book is spent on the run. Our carpenter and his merry band get themselves into and out of a number of perilous situations that ultimately ends in a cliffhanger eagerly awaiting the next book in the series. The plot moves forward at an OK pace, but there is nothing remotely original in it. Gowans creates some believable tension between the characters and the situations they find themselves in but the resolution to the tension is as bland as a nutri system cookie.
The thing that bothered me most about the series is that the characters don’t ever seem to evolve until the very last scene. Both Henry and Isabelle have very little depth. They are both kind to a fault and their relationship feels like a third grade romance. The most interesting character is the lovable rogue Ruther and he is not that lovable and not that roguish. What is seriously missing is a taste of the extreme. We read books either to learn or to escape. Sadly, this novel didn’t offer either of these things. I will not be continuing the series. This is one to skip.